You can find my new blog – plus extra pages and content – at stephenmenzie.com

Wednesday, July 04, 2012

Spot the difference

A while ago I threatened to write something about Spotted Flycatchers. The time has come.


I was in the museum today; well, what else can you do when the forecast looks like this?

My visit was largely to look at something other than Spotted Flycatchers, but I had a bit of spare time and couldn't resist a rumage through the Muscicapa tray.
NB the bird front-centre is moulting its legs. More on that later.

But let's start at the beginning. Conventional wisdom states that both age-classes of Spotted Flycatcher (i.e. adults and young birds) have a complete winter-moult; thus, by the time they return to Europe in spring, they can't be aged using plumage. That was the view I held until spring 2010 when I caught a bird in Catalonia that appeared to have retained some wing feathers.


The primary coverts were old, worn and brown; S3 on both wings was completely shagged (technical term); and, critical to ageing the bird at the time, the retained carpal coverts were tipped pale, i.e. juvenile feathers. So it should be possible to confidently age the bird as a 2cy. The winter moult of Spotted Flycatchers might not always be complete after all!

I took a close look at a couple more Spotted Flycatchers that I caught during the same period of ringing. Several other birds also showed primary coverts that seemed old and worn.

A look through the literure showed that an incomplete winter-moult wasn't unknown. Svensson describes the moult of the species as: “Ad.: sp, WC; (SC*WC). – Young: sp, WC; (sp, WC—).” Basically, in English, that means adults usual have a partial summer-moult and a complete winter-moult but that some adults may start their complete moult in summer, suspend it during migration, and complete it in the winter; and most young birds have a partial summer-moult and a complete winter-moult but that some young birds may have a partial summer-moult followed by a "complete" winter-moult that is suspended before it completes (i.e. leaving some feathers unmoulted).

BWP says on the matter: “Adult pre-breeding: Suspension of primary and secondary moult sometimes occurs before spring migration. Some birds complete moult of primaries, secondaries, and/or tertials, suspended during preceding autumn migration" and "First adult pre-breeding: Complete, as adult pre-breeding. In winter quarters, but later, extending to April or May”.

Jenni and Winkler go into even more detail with their assessment of moult on spring birds. Here's what they found:

Extent: usually whole plumage. According to our observations on 145 spring migrants in Italy, MaC, MeC, CC, Al, R and P were always moulted.
S:10.3% retained one to three central S: eight birds S 2-3, four birds S 3 and one bird S 2+4, S 3-5 and S 2, respectively. Sometimes,  S6 appeared older than the other S.
PC: PC appeared older than the P in 54% of the birds and sometimes the difference in wear was very distinct. One bird had PC 2-5 older than the other PC and the P.
GC: one bird retained GC 6 and 8.
T: in many birds, the T appeared more bleached and sometimes distinctly more abraded than the other remiges, in others one or two T appeared newer than the other wing-feathers.
They then go on to discuss the subject: “It appears that S 2–3, which may be retained during the prebr moult, are precisely those occasionally moulted during the postbr moult. Thus it seems that an interrupted prebr S-moult is resumed during the postbr moult. Whether the S renewed during the postbr moult are regularly skipped during the prebr moult remains unclear.
“Those PC that in spring often appear older than the P are more difficult to judge. Since no precise information about the extent and timing of PC-moult is available[*], it remains unclear whether the PC of some birds are moulted much earlier, just after arriving in the winter quarters, than the rest of the feathers or whether they are not moulted at all during the prebr moult as suggested by their heavy wear.”

Williamson (1992) says that “Moult of the primary coverts does not appear to be linked with the corresponding remiges as it is in other passerines”. It's interesting to note that Jenni and Winkler add to this in their publication with “...but probably before or at beginning of P moult”. They do go on to say that “Two birds in P-moult, examined by [Jenni & Winkler] in the Vienna Museum, showed PC already renewed (P 9–7 and P 4–1 growing, respectively)” so it might be unwise to cast any aspersions on their remark; but taking the Williamson statement purly at face value, I think it's best not to make any assumptions — the birds examined by Williamson may well have moulted their primary coverts already, but then again they may not have and they may never had; either would still be classed as "not linked" with the corresponding remiges.

[*] I'll pause briefly there to have a moan about primary-covert moult. Ask most ringers for an assessment of a bird's moult and they'll tell you how many primaries it's growing. Some of the more thoughtful ringers might also tell you about the secondaries but that's generally about it. Even the BTO ringing unit (and I'm going to get my licence taken off me for saying this) seem to have little idea of the value of primary coverts moult; indeed, in the BTO's ringing data programme, when I enter primary moult score I get told the number of primary coverts must equal ten. Well, I challange anyone to find the 10th primary covert on a Greenfinch! But anyway, the point being that the moult of primary coverts is often overlooked; a bird in primary moult will often be noted as being "in complete moult", even if the reality is that the bird is not moulting the corresponding primary coverts. Thus data from African wintering grounds of birds having a "complete moult" may have to be taken with a pinch of salt; the reality may well be that the birds were simply moulting primaries.

And to hammer the point home, Jenni and Winkler finish their paragraph on pre-breeding moult with: “It would be interesting to investigate whether or not the state of the PC in spring is age dependent, because 1y/2y of a number of species (e.g. Lanius senator, Sylvia communis, Carduelis chloris, C. spinus, Loxia curvirostra) which moult P, usually do not renew PC.”

There's an advantage to being at Falsterbo. They have a trick up their sleeve when it comes to ageing: iris colour (a subject that I will say more on another time). There is, with practice and experience, a difference in iris colour between second-year and 3+cy Spotted Flycatchers. Thus, it's possible to age birds; and to age them independent of plumage features. This added some extra interesting information to the Spotted Flycatcher moult story, although it also raises further questions that would be interesting to try and answer. So, think of this as a work in progress; something to check if you're ever in the company of a Spotted Flycatcher; but be aware that some things are still unknown and that I might even change my mind about some of these things in the future!

A lot of the photos I'm going to use come from the Falsterbo Bird Observatory photo project. Many similar photos have been used in publications by FBO, which can be found on their website publication pages.

Bird 1: This bird was aged as a 2cy using iris colour. The primary coverts are brown and worn.

Bird 2: This bird was aged as a 2cy using iris colour. The primary coverts are brown and worn; S2–3 were not moulted during the pre-breeding moult.

Bird 3: This bird was aged as a 2cy using iris colour. The primary coverts are brown and moderately worn; S1–4 and P1–2 were not moulted during the pre-breeding moult. P3 appears fresher/newer than the other moulted primaries; the inner primary coverts appear contrastingly less worn than the outer primary coverts. 

Bird 3: This individual had also retained two tail feathers, R1(left) and R2(right); much of the retained R1 had broken away while the retained R2 is in extremely poor condition.


Bird 4: This bird was aged as a 2cy using iris colour. The primary coverts are brown and moderately worn; the innermost primary covert is blacker and fresher — there was no contrast in the primary coverts on the left wing.

Bird 5: This bird was aged as a 3+cy using iris colour. The plumage is of a single generation; the primary coverts are dark, rounded and fresh.

Bird 6: This bird was aged as a 2cy using iris colour. The primary coverts are moderately brown but do not appear too worn. S1–4 and median covert 3 were not moulted during the pre-breeding moult, though note the contrast between the feather generations in the secondaries is not as obvious as in e.g. Bird 2 or Birds 3.

Bird 6: This individual had also retained at least two upper tail coverts. Pale makings at the tips of the retained feathers have all but worn away. The pattern of these pale tips, and the quality of the retained feathers, points towards them being juvenile feathers.

For reference — moulted adult-type upper tail coverts:

 — fresh juvenile upper tail coverts:

So, what can we say about ageing Spotted Flycatchers? On all of the birds ringed this spring, ageing with iris colour reached the same conclusion as ageing with plumage — note my careful wording of that statement. If we put faith in iris colour as a valid ageing tool, it appears that second-year birds and 3+cy birds can be aged on the basis of plumage. However, I'm reluctant to say it's so simple. There are several issues that need answering before we can say anything for sure.

  • Age ratio According to our ageing, only a few % of the 50 or so birds handled were 3+cy; the remainder were aged as 2cy. That seems an awfully skewed age breakdown. Maybe there are other factors at play? Perhaps 2cy are more likely to be grounded on their migration north, or similar, and thus more likely to be trapped.
  • Primary-covert moult There was variation in the degree of wear/bleaching to the primary coverts. Is this because some birds keep the feathers in better condition than others? Or do some individuals moult the primary coverts whilst others don't? If the latter, are the moulted primary coverts a distinct and identifiable "first adult" type? There's quite a difference between the primary coverts of e.g. Bird 6 and Bird 2; but, as Björn Malmhagen said to me at the time, the primary coverts of Bird 6 "just don't give the appearance of being adult feathers". And he's right; there is still a clear difference between the primary coverts on Bird 6 and Bird 5.
  • Genuine complete 1/2cy moult Even if we establish that we can age some birds as 2cy following an incomplete winter-moult, can we safely age them all using the same characteristics? If some first-winter birds can undergo a complete moult then plumage alone may only be safe enough to age birds as 2cy and 2+cy (though the above comments re: "first adult" plumage may come into play here).
  • Incomplete adult moult On a similar note, how often do adults leave feathers unmoulted? Do they ever leave feathers unmoulted?
  • Known age birds A critical point worth bearing in mind. So critical, in fact, I'm going to write it in block capticals. NONE OF THE BIRDS IN THIS BLOG POST ARE OF KNOWN AGE. It's easy to create a self fulfilling prophecy, though using two (apparently) independent criteria should at least lessen the chances if that happening. However, in order to come to a definite conclusion, ringed birds of known age need to be studied — a project for the future?

Finally, back to the museum. I hate museum specimens; they smell, they're stiff, they're often contorted or discoloured, and the wings are clamped tight shut. That makes it hard to examine them for signs of moult, especially so if you're checking the outer secondaries. However, there's certainly no easier way to get your mitts on 30 Spotted Flycatchers in the space of an hour or two.

Of the 30 or so skins I examined, I could find only one with any retained feathers; a bird with S2–3 unmoulted.
Can you see it?

That's not to say other birds didn't also have retained secondaries/primaries, just that I didn't manage to find any. For completeness, here's a shot of the same bird's primary coverts.

The other problem with museum skins is that the specimens are often old and brittle. Quite often you take a bird out of the drawer to find its legs fall out, or its wing flops about, or its head drops off and rolls across the floor. Remember the bird in the very first photo that was moulting its legs? It was also moulting its left wing... That did have an advantage, though; I could hold that bird's wing right up close to another birds wing to compare. The "moulting" individual had worn, brown, narrow primary coverts; the bird I chose to compare it with had fresh, dark, rounded primary coverts. Both birds were 'taken' in May so they should be comparable.

And for anyone who's made it this far down the page, very well done!

Many thanks to FBO for use of the images, to Tony Parker at National Museums Liverpool, and to Björn and everyone else at Falsterbo who fuelled my interest in the subject.

Maybe I should just stick with Woodpigeons...

Tuesday, July 03, 2012

Variation in albifrons primaries

From cute fluffy chicks to something a little more nerdy. Little Terns have what Malling Olsen & Larsson describe as a "complex" moult; and using the word complex in relation to tern moult is really saying something! Focusing on the primary moult of adults — since that is the most obvious in the field — birds have a complete post-breeding moult including all of the primaries; it starts with the inner primaries on the breeding grounds, is suspended while the bird migrates, is resumed on the wintering grounds and finishes with the outer primaries in about December. Let's call the primaries grown during this complete moult "series one". At the same time, starting a month or two before the completion of series one, a second wave of primary moult starts again at P1 (innermost primary). Let's call this second wave "series two". A month or two after series two starts, another new wave of primary moult ("series three") starts; series one has now finished but both series two and series three are simultaneously active. Primary moult is suspended "at onset of breeding" by which time series two has usually reached about P8 and series three has reached about P3. Thus a bird arriving back at the breeding colony would have a right wing something like
(body/tertials/secondaries)3332222211
where 1 = series one and so on.


There is some limited variation in the extent of the primary moult, most noticeably in the number of black outer primaries (2–3 on most birds, sometimes 1, per Malling Olsen & Larsson exceptionally 4). These outer primaries (retained from "series one") are pretty old and worn, hence their dark appearance. The most common number of retained outer primaries on birds at Gronant appears to be two.

A bird with two retained outer primaries has a classic Littler Tern pattern; in the field, the dark primaries (and their corresponding primary coverts) give the appearance of a dark leading edge to the outer wing.

Notice how, even with a relatively good photos, it can be difficult (impossible?) to detect the moult limit between series two and series three.

Some birds in the colony showed three outer primaries.
It may only be one primary difference but notice how having three retained outer primaries transforms the appearance of the wing; the dark leading edge is now a more conspicuous dark wedge.


The number of retained outer primaries is listed as a feature for separating albifrons (Little Tern) from saundersi (Saunders's Tern breeding in Asia and East Africa), with the latter showing 3–4 retained primaries. So, how does one separate our "three retained primary" Little Terns from a Saunders's Tern. Apart from the fact we're in Wales, obviously. A Saunders's Tern should show even blacker outer primaries with a black feather shaft; you can just about make out, on the lower bird in the photos above at least, that the shaft on the outer primaries is quite pale. Saunders's Tern also shows a squarer forehead patch with the white stopping short of the eye; you can see on both of these birds that the white extends to behind the eye giving making the rear border of the white patch sharply pointed. So, good, we've established that Saunders's Tern isn't breeding in north Wales.

I also photographed one bird that shows only one retained outer primary.

An extensive primary moult like this takes us in the opposite direction from Saunders's Tern, to North American and to antillarum (Least Tern). Least Tern is reported to show on average fewer retained primaries than Littler Tern. So, how can we rule out Least Tern? The most reliable feature seems to be the rump/tail colour: concolourous with the mantle in Least Tern but contrasting white in Little Tern. This bird clearly shows a white rump/tail that contrasts with the grey mantle and thus is (unsurprisingly) a Little Tern. Perhaps the easiest way to pick out a Least Tern in a Little Tern colony is by voice — I kept an ear open for anything squeaky while we were ringing the chicks but with no success!

Finally, going full circle with the moult, a small number of adults birds at the colony had already started their post-breeding primary moult. The result: four generations of primaries in one wing!
P9-10 series one (old); P4-8 series two; P3 series three; P1-2 just starting to grow as part of (new) series one.

Sunday, July 01, 2012

Little Terns


I spent most of today at the Little Tern colony in Gronant, north Wales, with David Norman and Jason Atkinson. There was plenty of adult activity around the colony, which gave me chance to attempt some flight shots.



But of course that wasn't the reason we were there; we were there to looks for these:

For the last 30 years, David has obtained a Schedule 1 permit to ring and study the Little Tern chicks in the colony. Today we found and ringed 14 individuals. They often move out of the main colony soon after hatching and can be difficult to find; on our first pass through the dunes we found three individuals but on our second pass through several hours later we refound only one of them (along with a couple of new individuals that we had missed the first time round). Some are easier to find than others...
If I can't see you...

Younger chicks were often easier to find as they hadn't moved far from the nest; and most of the nests have been marked by the wardens. The right hand bird of this pair is <48 hrs old; the left hand bird is <24 hrs.


And finally — especially for Faab — here are some wing shots of Friday's Woodpigeons. The 2cy:

And the 3+cy:

Friday, June 29, 2012

A double dose of palumbus

The walk-in trap is continuing to work well. This afternoon it got a double hit with this pair of Woodpigeons — the female made her way through the tunnel and was almost straight away followed by the male.

The female was a 2cy and the male was a 3+cy in case you were wondering. You weren't? Oh, never mind then.

Wednesday, June 27, 2012

Raptor watching

There was one less Goldfinch left in the garden this morning but at least this male Sparrowhawk got some breakfast:

And talking of Sparrowhawks (tenuous link), it's a real shame I won't be able to make it out to Georgia this autumn — it looks like the Batumi Bird Festival is going to be great.


For anyone who wants more info on visiting the festival, there's plenty on the BRC website http://www.batumiraptorcount.org/projects/batumi-bird-festival

Tuesday, June 26, 2012

Pre-rain ringing

I joined David Norman for a few hours ringing this morning before the forecast rain arrived — it looks like the next few days are going to be better for desk-based work rather than being in the field. Ringing was — at least in relation to how it could have been — fairly slow, though we did catch a number of warblers; the best of the lot was this juvenile Grasshopper Warbler:

The bird was still in the final stages of growing its flight feathers, indicating that it won't travelled far from the nest in which it hatched. We also caught several female birds of several species that had active brood-patches, suggesting that breeding is still on-going for individuals.

Monday, June 25, 2012

The final few days

I'm just back from dropping Fabian off at the airport; I should start by saying what a pleasure it has been to have him here and — despite the weather — we've had a great week.

On Saturday we visited a few local sites in the hope of finding a flavissima Yellow Wagtail but we had no luck. Everywhere seems unnervingly quiet this spring for breeding songbirds — for example, many sites that would usually hold multiple Reed and Sedge Warblers seem to have just one or two birds.

We paid a visit to Neumann's Flash where the only bird of any real note was a Black Swan...

Yesterday we headed up to the Peak District where, after dipping them in Wales last week, we managed to find some Red Grouse — a lifer for Fabian. We wandered up onto the moor for a closer look until the heavens opened and we took shelter back in the car.

Once the rain had stopped, we walked along the river valley where we found a ('brown bellied') Dipper, a new subspecies for Fabian and a bird that's always great value to watch as it dips and dives through the rough water.

In the car park, a Lesser Redpoll showed well and a Short-eared Owl passing over was a pleasant surprise.

Back at home we set the walk-in trap in the garden and — after a lengthy period of a Woodpigeon walking round and round the trap, then poking its head into the entrance tunnel and backing out again — success!

We aged the bird as a 3+cy (EURING 6); I'll save the gory details for another day.

In the evening (after a meal of scouse to add some authenticity for Faab's visit), we headed down to Woolston where we put up a few nets. In the short time they were open we caught five birds, including a juvenile Willow Tit. Then we relaxed for the evening before camping overnight.

We started early this morning, opening all the nets; over the morning we caught 48 birds including another juvenile Willow Tit, some juvenile Wrens, Blackcaps, Common Chiffchaffs and Willow Warblers, and several Bullfinches.

The trap at home continued to catch well this afternoon, admittedly mostly Feral Pigeons but also a female Blackbird, both of 'our' Robins, and a juvenile House Sparrow (quite a scarce bird in our neighbourhood, so nice to see they've bred somewhere reasonably close by).

Friday, June 22, 2012

A nice little surprise

We were in Tesco buying some extra value white bread (more on that later) when news came through of  a Little Swift at New Brighton. Holy Apus! It wouldn't stick though, would it? No, of course it wouldn't. So we carried on with our original plans. A few minutes later and another news message later and we cracked. Half an hour later and we were pulling up into the car park at New Brighton. We were expecting brief and probably distant views of the bird... so it was a pleasant surprise when the bird flew over the car at head height before we'd even stepped out.

The bird was feeding over the car park and along the river embankment; it was often low, flying by within a metre or two of the assembled crowd! And it often flew low over the sand, giving a nice chance for a top view. Sadly, both Fabian and I had left our camera/large lens combos at home — but Faab did have his 28–50 mm lens with him... and that was good enough!

Here's my effort with just an iPhone:

And a slightly iffy video (there's more action in the second half):


Here's a few of Faab's photos; there are more on his blog:



The bird looked amazingly fresh, with pale fringes to all of the wing feathers (including a thin trailing edge to the wing) — photos back up what we could see in the field (e.g. see Jason Atkinson's blog); photos also show pale fringes to e.g. the upper tail coverts, which I hadn't seen in the field. Occasionally it looked like there was a break in the outer primaries but this seemed to come and go and I suspect it was just misplaced feathers rather than any actual damage (or moult). BWP states that eggs are laid mid-April. Incubation is c.20 days and birds fledge after c.40 days. That's a total of 60 days from laying to fledging, which — for a bird from an early nesting pair — would put fledging around mid-June. So, the plumage fits with the bird being a juvenile and, assuming this bird was early hatched, so does the timing.

But back to the white loaf. Fabian and I spent most of yesterday afternoon/evening building a wire walk-in trap to put in the garden with the aim of catching Woodpigeons and other large birds. We deployed the trap this morning with mixed results: one retrap Robin (the male of the breeding pair) and two Grey Squirrels. At least the garden is now squirrel free...

The trap has been baited for the reminder of the afternoon but so far nothing. Fingers crossed for tomorrow.