We had hoped, after yesterday, for a net full of rarities this morning but instead we got a net full of Robins; well, 60 of them over the morning anyway, making up one-third of the 89 birds ringed (totals online — click Ringing). We did score two very nice scarcities, our second Hawfinch of the season and our first Wryneck.
The Wryneck was the only the 4th to be ringed at the lighthouse during spring standardised ringing this century. It was a smart 3+cy birds, easily aged using the pattern of the primary coverts. Compare today's bird, which has only a single generation of fresh primary coverts with only a single terminal pale dot on the outer web:
...with a 2cy photographed two years ago almost to the day in Spain, which has two generations of primary coverts (a variable number are moulted during the pre-formative [post-juvenile] moult) — the inner are adult type; the outer are retained juvenile feathers, rather worn and showing a terminal pale dot on both the inner and the outer web of the feather:
And a few more photos because, well, just because.
This morning's Hawfinch was a 2cy female.
The wing showed a moult limit in the greater coverts with three retained juvenile feathers:
Compare that to last week's 3+cy female on which all the wing feathers are a single generation. It is also brighter with wider grey fringing to the secondaries and more white on the primaries with 'fancier' (wider) primary tips:
Sightings over the morning included a Whimbrel and a couple of Barn Swallows.
In the afternoon, Arvid and I took a wander around the old rubbish dump at the north of the peninsula, adding Arctic Tern (x8) and House Martin (x1) to my year list in the process. Also a Greenshank and a Green Sandpiper.
The pair of Eider and the Red-necked Grebe were still on the harbour road pools.
Here it is puking up a fish.
Talking of which...
continued from page 1.
The Wryneck was the only the 4th to be ringed at the lighthouse during spring standardised ringing this century. It was a smart 3+cy birds, easily aged using the pattern of the primary coverts. Compare today's bird, which has only a single generation of fresh primary coverts with only a single terminal pale dot on the outer web:
...with a 2cy photographed two years ago almost to the day in Spain, which has two generations of primary coverts (a variable number are moulted during the pre-formative [post-juvenile] moult) — the inner are adult type; the outer are retained juvenile feathers, rather worn and showing a terminal pale dot on both the inner and the outer web of the feather:
And a few more photos because, well, just because.
This morning's Hawfinch was a 2cy female.
The wing showed a moult limit in the greater coverts with three retained juvenile feathers:
Compare that to last week's 3+cy female on which all the wing feathers are a single generation. It is also brighter with wider grey fringing to the secondaries and more white on the primaries with 'fancier' (wider) primary tips:
Sightings over the morning included a Whimbrel and a couple of Barn Swallows.
In the afternoon, Arvid and I took a wander around the old rubbish dump at the north of the peninsula, adding Arctic Tern (x8) and House Martin (x1) to my year list in the process. Also a Greenshank and a Green Sandpiper.
The pair of Eider and the Red-necked Grebe were still on the harbour road pools.
Here it is puking up a fish.
*****
So, yesterday I threatened to get some sleep and write something more about the Black-shouldered Kite (Appologies to any Australian readers who think I'm talking about E. axillaris. I'm not; I'm talking about E. caeruleus "Black-winged Kite". Except I refuse to use that name). Well, here we go. I'll start with identification. It might seem pretty given that the bird is a Black-shouldered Kite, but the thought did cross my mind whilst I was watching the bird "Why not a [escaped] White-tailed Kite?" — because, being British, no twitch would be complete without at least one grumbling of 'escape'. I had a vague recollection that White-tailed Kite had a longer tail but could remember nothing more than that. It seems, from a quick Google, that I was right; White-tailed has a tail that projects beyond the wingtips, Black-shouldered falls short of the wing tips. On our bird, the tail was clearly shorter than the wing tips. And... despite having the same plumage pattern, White-tailed looks really different. So, sorted. BOOM!
Then there was the matter of racial identification. That was quite easy, actually, since the first views we had of the bird were as it flew over. The underside to the secondaries was pale/white, as in European/African caeruleus; on the Asian subspecies vociferous , the black on the underside of the primaries continues onto the underside of the secondaries. Done. BOOM!
How about the age of the bird? Virtually all the literature you read will tell you that Black-shouldered Kites have a complete post-juvenile moult. Forsman confuses things by stating that moult is complete then, in a later paragraph, stating it is partial (or vice versa, I don't have a copy to hand at the moment)... Then things are confused even more by the fact that birds are reported as diagnosable as immatures well beyond being in juvenile plumage. A conversation with David Erterius whilst in the field confirmed that Sweden's first record had been aged as a 2cy on the basis of retained juvenile (or, erm, juvenile-type?) primary coverts. So that was my first challenge: get a look at the primary coverts. I managed one view of the bird's primary coverts as it preened but views were brief (like proper brief; when I say one view, I mean one flash of the primary coverts but the bird put them away again), and I was watching it at the time through — with all due respect to André's scope — André's crappy scope. To me, the primary coverts looked grey with a thin white terminal fringe, which would have made them juvenile-type — but I really wasn't willing to pin anything on that given the brief views I got.
So, what do the photos show? This photo seems to suggest that the pale is actually at the base of the visible primaries. However, the right wing in this photo seems to suggest there is indeed a pale fringe to the primary coverts... however, the left wing in the same photo suggests there isn't any pale at all! So a trick of the light? Perhaps best to forget about the primary coverts altogether and look for something else.
On the perched bird, I thought I could see a secondary or two that looked like the sort of thing I could have made into retained feathers — but views weren't good enough to work out if they were or if it was just shadow or a misplaced feather and I couldn't see it on the photos on the back of my camera. However, a close look at my photos once I got home seemed to confirm this; that there were two generations of secondaries, and that the older ones appeared shorter and browner.
Does this age the bird, though? A bird's secondaries are usually moulted last in the moult process so, if an individual is going to leave any feathers unmoulted, it's generally a secondary or two. I've seen unmoulted secondaries on adult Eurasian Nightjar and adult Common Cuckoo — interestingly, both species where the young undergo complete (or near-complete) post-juvenile moults; and indeed the juveniles of both commonly leave some secondaries unmoulted. So, the presence of unmoulted secondaries per se doesn't prove the bird is a 2cy. The unmoulted feathers themselves might give us some clues — the fact they're shorter and browner certainly suggests they're likely to be retained juvenile feathers — but really, without better photos/the bird in the hand, and with a sever lack of knowledge of the moult of the species, it's probably best not making any assumptions using the secondaries.
However, there's something else on the bird that I think does safely age it, which I didn't notice in the field but is clear on some photographs. The best — or at least what appears to be the best — reference I have found for moult and ageing in Black-shouldered Kite is Javier Blasco's online guide. It states "Usually a complete postjuvenile moult, but some birds can retain some juvenile outer primaries". There should be no reason why an adult would not moult its primaries (or, if it did, it should have a whole load of unmoulted secondaries to go with it, not just one or two). So...
Check the outer primary on the left wing! It's brown and appears quite worn (some photos even seem to show it being a bit bashed-up at the tip). As a sort of control, check out the outer primary on the right wing:
It's all black and nice and doesn't contrast with the rest of the primaries at all. So, we don't have to worry about the outer primaries being "naturally different" or anything like that. Moult is occasionally asymmetrical, so there's nothing to worry about with that either. All-in-all, I think we can probably be fairly confident that the outer primary on the left wing is a retained juvenile feather; ergo the bird is a 2cy. BOOM!
And one final BOOM! http://waarneming.nl/foto/view/3169284 Dutch bird, 13-04-2012, retained juvenile primary on the left wing. BOOOOOOOOM!
OK, I promise never to use the BOOM! again.
How about the age of the bird? Virtually all the literature you read will tell you that Black-shouldered Kites have a complete post-juvenile moult. Forsman confuses things by stating that moult is complete then, in a later paragraph, stating it is partial (or vice versa, I don't have a copy to hand at the moment)... Then things are confused even more by the fact that birds are reported as diagnosable as immatures well beyond being in juvenile plumage. A conversation with David Erterius whilst in the field confirmed that Sweden's first record had been aged as a 2cy on the basis of retained juvenile (or, erm, juvenile-type?) primary coverts. So that was my first challenge: get a look at the primary coverts. I managed one view of the bird's primary coverts as it preened but views were brief (like proper brief; when I say one view, I mean one flash of the primary coverts but the bird put them away again), and I was watching it at the time through — with all due respect to André's scope — André's crappy scope. To me, the primary coverts looked grey with a thin white terminal fringe, which would have made them juvenile-type — but I really wasn't willing to pin anything on that given the brief views I got.
So, what do the photos show? This photo seems to suggest that the pale is actually at the base of the visible primaries. However, the right wing in this photo seems to suggest there is indeed a pale fringe to the primary coverts... however, the left wing in the same photo suggests there isn't any pale at all! So a trick of the light? Perhaps best to forget about the primary coverts altogether and look for something else.
On the perched bird, I thought I could see a secondary or two that looked like the sort of thing I could have made into retained feathers — but views weren't good enough to work out if they were or if it was just shadow or a misplaced feather and I couldn't see it on the photos on the back of my camera. However, a close look at my photos once I got home seemed to confirm this; that there were two generations of secondaries, and that the older ones appeared shorter and browner.
Does this age the bird, though? A bird's secondaries are usually moulted last in the moult process so, if an individual is going to leave any feathers unmoulted, it's generally a secondary or two. I've seen unmoulted secondaries on adult Eurasian Nightjar and adult Common Cuckoo — interestingly, both species where the young undergo complete (or near-complete) post-juvenile moults; and indeed the juveniles of both commonly leave some secondaries unmoulted. So, the presence of unmoulted secondaries per se doesn't prove the bird is a 2cy. The unmoulted feathers themselves might give us some clues — the fact they're shorter and browner certainly suggests they're likely to be retained juvenile feathers — but really, without better photos/the bird in the hand, and with a sever lack of knowledge of the moult of the species, it's probably best not making any assumptions using the secondaries.
A better view of the retained secondaries from above. Is there pale fringing to the tips of the primary coverts? — photo © Martin Alexandersson
However, there's something else on the bird that I think does safely age it, which I didn't notice in the field but is clear on some photographs. The best — or at least what appears to be the best — reference I have found for moult and ageing in Black-shouldered Kite is Javier Blasco's online guide. It states "Usually a complete postjuvenile moult, but some birds can retain some juvenile outer primaries". There should be no reason why an adult would not moult its primaries (or, if it did, it should have a whole load of unmoulted secondaries to go with it, not just one or two). So...
© Martin Alexandersson
© Martin Alexandersson
It's all black and nice and doesn't contrast with the rest of the primaries at all. So, we don't have to worry about the outer primaries being "naturally different" or anything like that. Moult is occasionally asymmetrical, so there's nothing to worry about with that either. All-in-all, I think we can probably be fairly confident that the outer primary on the left wing is a retained juvenile feather; ergo the bird is a 2cy. BOOM!
And one final BOOM! http://waarneming.nl/foto/view/3169284 Dutch bird, 13-04-2012, retained juvenile primary on the left wing. BOOOOOOOOM!
OK, I promise never to use the BOOM! again.





















No comments:
Post a Comment