But this afternoon, whilst doing the weekly bird count on Knösen, I was unfortunate enough to stubble across this:
Erm, yes. Looks good, doesn't it? Or like a right pain in the rarity committee submission form arse, depending on how you look at it.
When I first picked the bird up it was some distance off and the bill looked mostly black. There was clearly a very small amount of yellow just by the lores and, at certain angles, you could convince yourself that there was some yellow along the edge of the base of the bill. The culmen was definitely completely black right up to the bill base and, at the distance it was at, the bill pattern looked symmetrical. What's more, despite the range, the yellow on the three Bewick's Swans it was (loosely*) hanging out with was still perfectly visible. In all other ways (size, shape etc), this bird wasn't any different to the Bewick's Swans.
*it was usually a good five or so metres away from the other three birds, which always kept close together, and when it did try to join them it was shunned away.
I rang Björn to discuss the bird but when I looked back, shit, they had gone. Thankfully they hadn't flown far and were now settled (slightly) closer; close enough for me to see a bit more detail on the bill. And then things didn't look so rosy for stringing a columbianus. The yellow/yellowish was more extensive than it had looked at a distance and seemed to be asymmetrical. A small patch in front of the lores was still the only solid visible yellow on the bill; but on the right side, there seemed to be two diffuse spurs of yellow projecting out into the bill (the lower one of which was probably giving the hint of yellow along the edge of the bill base at distance); and on the left side, there appeared to be a single diffuse spur with a detached end blob. Here's an artist's impression of what I reckon I saw based entirely on field sketches I made at the time. If you squint a bit you get a better idea of what I saw through the scope:
Bear in mind that the bird was being viewed at 500m range in windy conditions. It really wouldn't surprise me if closer views revealed a slightly different bill pattern — but nonetheless, I am reasonably happy that the pattern generally pattern is drawn broadly more-or-less right, that the pattern is not symmetrical, and that the extent of yellow/yellowish should rule out columbianus.
So, what is it? The neat answer seems to be some sort of intergrade. Still nice since that would mean 1. it's come from quite a long way away and 2. it seems like there are only 3 or 4 records of birds like this previously recorded in Sweden. The nagging question I have at the back of my mind: how can we rule out a dodgy bewickii? I'll try and look for the bird again tomorrow and hope it's giving better views.
Causing less of an identification headache, other birds seen at Knösen included a Marsh Harrier, a White-tailed Eagle, a Peregrine, a Woodcock, and a flock of Avocets.



No comments:
Post a Comment